slide 1: ________________________________________
Author for correspondence E-mail: a_senthilkumar03yahoo.co.in prof.praveenrajangmail.com
Int. J. Chem. Sci.: 14S2 2016 597-608
ISSN 0972-768X
www.sadgurupublications.com
OPTIMIZATION OF FAN SPEED IN VAV AIR
CONDITIONING USING ANN
A. SENTHILKUMAR
R. PRAVEEN P. KUMARAN and
R. MAHESH
Department of Mechanical Engineering Aarupadai Veedu Institute of Technology Paiyanoor
KANCHIPURAM T.N. INDIA
ABSTRACT
The Variable Air Volume VAV system is considered to be a promising air conditioning scheme
in most of the heating ventilation and air conditioning HVAC applications. It is designed to deliver
variable airflow rate for varying thermal load conditions prevailing inside the conditioned space. This
paper reports the application of artificial neural network to optimize the fan speed in a variable air volume
system. Based on the polynomial model for various supply voltage and airflow rate the fan performance
curves were obtained. These curves show a deviation from the real curves. Experimental results were
utilized for training the artificial neural network ANN model. The optimized ANN model curves show
less deviation with that of the real curves. This optimization technique can be used to predict the thermal
comfort to be maintained in the conditioned space.
Key words: Artificial neural network Fan speed Optimization Thermal comfort VAV.
INTRODUCTION
In modern building air conditioning applications the concept of variable air volume
VAV system has a significant role in maintaining the thermal comfort inside the building
envelope by delivering a varied quantity of supply air to satisfy the thermal load fluctuations
persisting in the conditioned space. An interesting feature of VAV system utilizing a
variable speed fan is that a substantial quantity of energy savings is possible. However the
fan performance is greatly influenced by the quantity of air delivered into the conditioned
space.
Bennakhi et al.
1
Presented general regression neural networks GRNNs used to
optimize air conditioning set back scheduling in public buildings. The objective was to
slide 2: A. Senthilkumar et al.: Optimization of Fan Speed in…. 598
predict the time of the need of thermostat setback EoS such that the design temperature
inside the building was restored in time for the start of business hours. State of the art
building simulation software ESP-r was used to generate a database that covered the past
five years. The robustness of the trained neural network NN was tested by applying them
to a “production” data set. The results showed that the neural control-scheme was a powerful
instrument for optimizing air conditioning setback scheduling based on external temperature
records. D. J. Swider et al.
2
presented the modeling of vapor compression liquid chillers. The
generalized radial basis function networks have been successfully applied to two different
chillers. The neural network predicted the compressor work input and the COP within ± 5
error for the single circulated chiller and the more complex twin circulated chiller. The
developed general regression radial basis function chiller model was applied to chiller
system and sufficient amount of measured steady state data were obtained.
D. J. Moschandreas and S. W. Choi
3
performed two series of experiments in an
aluminum chamber under controlled conditions to investigate whether the variable-air-
volume/bypass filtration system VAV/BPFS reduces indoor air pollutant concentrations
relative to a conventional variable-air-volume VAV system. The particulate matter
VAV/BPFS total effective removal rate was 50 higher than the corresponding VAV total
effective removal rate. Also the VAV/BPFS total volatile organic compound total that the
VAV/BPFS system is a promising alternative to the conventional VAV system because
under the conditions tested it was capable of reducing and maintaining good indoor quality
and decreasing outdoor supply air rate. Erick Jeannette
4
explained the significance of
artificial neural networks for improved control of processes through predictive techniques.
They introduced and showed that experimental results of a predictive neural network PNN
controller applied to an unstable hot water system in an air-handling unit minimized the
process fluctuations reasonably.
Haruro Uehara et al.
5
presented a neural network model to control an ammonia
refrigerant evaporator. A dynamic synaptic unit DSU was proposed to enhance the
information processing capacity of artificial neurons. The NN architecture has been
compared with two other conventional architectures one with dynamic neural units DNU’S
and other with non linear static functions as perceptron. The objective was to control
evaporator heat flow rate and secondary fluid outlet temperature while keeping the degree of
refrigerant superheat in the range of 4-7 K at the evaporator outlet by manipulating
refrigerant and evaporator secondary fluid flow rates. The drawbacks of conventional
approaches to this problem are discussed and how neural method can overcome them are
presented.
slide 3: Int. J. Chem. Sci.: 14S2 2016 599
Jin Wen and Theodore F.Smith
6
presented the energy consumption by heating
ventilating and air conditioning HVAC systems has evoked increasing attention to promote
energy efficient control operation of HVAC systems. In this paper online models with
parameter estimation for a building zone with a variable air volume system were developed
and validated using experimental data. Kevin S. Maki
7
investigated outside air delivery and
thermal comfort in a normally operating variable-air-volume VAV system. The scope of
this paper was to cover some of the practical findings obtained regarding airflow
measurements in a VAV system. It was concluded that unless a VAV system was well
understood or continuously monitored the likelihood of unexpected system behavior that
cane be impact the outside air delivery and thermal comfort was high.
M.Hosoz
8
dealt the applicability of artificial neural networks ANNs to predict the
performance of automotive air conditioning ACC systems using HFC134a as the
refrigerant. They developed an experimental plant comprising of original components from
the air conditioning system of a compact size passenger vehicle. Experimental data were
used to train the ANN model of the system based on the standard back propagation
algorithm. The ANN predictions were agreed well with the experimental values. Mehmet
Azmi Aktacir et al.
9
presented a life cycle cost analysis using detailed load profiles and
initial and operating costs to evaluate the economic feasibilities of constant air volume
CAV and variable-air-volume VAV air-conditioning systems. It was found that the
present worth cost of the VAV system was always lower than that of the CAV system at the
end of the lifetime for all the cases considered.
Osman Ahmed
10
presented feed forward controllers having the unique aspects of
achieving energy savings with the variable-air-volume VAV system. The combined
feedforward-feedback approach was found to outperform the conventional feedback
controller. The combined approach uses a general regression neural network GRNN to
identify the parameter of the component characteristics and control. The combined approach
showed good results in terms of providing stable and accurate pressure control over a wide
operating range and with different damper characteristics. Shimming Deng and Wu Chen
11
reported the development of a representative and complete dynamic mathematical model for
the DX VAV A/C system having a variable speed compressor and pressure independent
VAV terminals. The model was component based and takes into account the dynamic
behaviors of both the DX refrigeration plant and the VAV air distribution subsystem
simultaneously. Experimental work has been conducted to obtain the system responses to the
step change of compressor speed. The dynamic model developed was then validated using
the experimental data obtained. Steady state and transient responses for operating parameters
obtained from both the model and the experiment were compared and found to be
satisfactory.
slide 4: A. Senthilkumar et al.: Optimization of Fan Speed in…. 600
Soteris A. Kalogiru
12
presented paper in various applications of neural networks in
energy problems in a thematic manner rather then chronological or any other order. It
included the use of artificial neural networks in heating ventilating and air conditioning
system modeling and control of power generation systems load forecasting and prediction
and refrigeration. The algorithm employed for the estimation of the flow of energy and
performances of systems were complicated having solution of complex differential
equations. Instead of complex rules and mathematical routines artificial neural networks
were able to learn the key information pattern with in a multidimensional information
domain. Neural network tool predicts energy prediction and modeling.
Tuncay Tanyolu
13
represented a method that generalized various conditions in the
plate finned-tube finned tube cooling and heating coils. An artificial neural network ANN
with principal component analysis PCA has been used as an inverse plant identifier.
Correlation among input and output temperatures of dry and wet air and water temperatures
through the plate finned-tube coils has been modeled using ANN. A self-organized principal
component analysis network SOPCAN was used as a processing technique. Eight percent
of the data were evaluated for the training and the remaining for the test using multilayer
perceptron network MLPN with back-propagation algorithm. Principal component that had
small variance were discarded and the reduced number of uncorrelated variables were
applied to the MLPN.The effects of discarding these components on the convergence of the
algorithm were investigated.
Artificial neural network
Artificial neural network models are used as alternative methods in engineering
analysis and predictions. ANN is capable of handing tasks involving incomplete data sets
complex and ill-defined problems and non-linear problems. The artificial neural network
consists of many nodes which are called as processing units analogous to neurons present in
the human brain. Each node has a node function associated with it which along with a set of
local parameters determines the output of the node given an input. Modifying the local
parameter may alter the node function. Artificial neural networks are an information
processing system. In information processing system the elements called neurons process
the information. The signals are transmitted by means of connection links. The links posses
an associated weight which is multiplied along with incoming signal net input for any
typical neural net. The output signal is obtained by applying activations to the net input.
The multilayered neural network is represented in Fig. 1. The knowledge of the
network is stored as a set of connection weights. Training is the process of modifying the
connection weights in some orderly fashion using a suitable learning method. In this type of
slide 5: Int. J. Chem. Sci.: 14S2 2016 601
network a layer of input units is connected to a layer of hidden units which is connected to a
layer of output units. The activity of neurons in the input layer represents the raw
information that is fed in to the network. The activity of neurons in the hidden layer is
determined by the activities of the input neurons and the connecting weights between the
input and hidden units. The behavior of the output units depend on the activity of the
neurons in the hidden layer and the connecting weights between the hidden and the outputs
layers. In this context X1 X2 X3 are the input neurons Y1 Y2 Y3 are the output neurons
and b is the bias of the neuron.
X
1
X
2
X
3
Y1
Y
2
Y
3
Fig. 1: Multi layered neural network
ANN model of fan
Neural networks are able to approximate many continuous non-linear functions to a
pre-specified accuracy and are used to express the unknown non-linear function.
m
W
1
1 1
W 11 2
W
1
1 3
W
2
2 1
W
2
2 2
W
2
2 3
W 2 1
W
2
2
W
2
3
∑
b 2
ΔP
Input layer
Hidden layer
Output layer
b
1
1
b
3
1
Fig. 2: ANN model of fan
slide 6: A. Senthilkumar et al.: Optimization of Fan Speed in…. 602
Start
DEFINE THE WEIGHTED
FUNCTION BIAS AND
ACTIV ATION FUNCTION
ANN
NETWORK
INPUT PARAMETERS SUPPLY
VOLTAGE AIRFLOW RATE AND
OUTPUT PARAMETER: TOTAL
PRESSURE RISE
BACK PROPAGATION OF
ERROR
OUTPUT
IF
SATISFIED
OPTIMIZED
OUTPUT TOTAL
PRESSURE RISE
NO
YES
Fig. 3: Flow chart for neuron model of fan
The model is estimated by using a widely applied multilayer perceptron MLP
neural network. The main purpose of this estimation is to use the data obtained from the real
characteristics curves to train the neural network. Trained ANN algorithm helps produce the
optimized value. The ANN fan model is depicted in Fig. 2. The input parameters considered
were supply voltage and air flow rate and the output parameter was total pressure rise. Fig. 3
show the flow diagram for the neuron model of fan.
Experimental methodology
A single zone VAV air handling system was considered for analysis. The schematic
representation of the system is shown in Fig. 4. The system comprises of an air handling unit
equipped with refrigeration circuit variable speed fan return air fan air distribution system
building scale model and sensors. The system was made to operate on cooling mode. Only
slide 7: Int. J. Chem. Sci.: 14S2 2016 603
20 of fresh air is drawn into the system and it get mixed with 80 of recirculated air in the
mixing plenum and the cold air depending on the load fluctuation was delivered into the
conditioned space by variable speed fan through supply air duct.
Fig. 4: Schematic representation of single zone VAV system
Artificial neural network optimization technique was used to control the fan speed.
The temperature in the zone and static pressure in the supply air duct were the parameters
considered to maintain the thermal comfort in the zone. The occupancy load pattern obtained
for the software laboratory located in Anna University on a summer design day is shown in
Fig. 5. A scale model of the software laboratory was built and experiment was conducted.
The total pressure rise between the entry and the exit of the supply fan was measured.
Fig. 5: Occupancy load pattern
slide 8: A. Senthilkumar et al.: Optimization of Fan Speed in…. 604
Fig. 6: Photographic view of VAV Air
system conditioning
Fig. 7: View of supply and return duct
system
The static pressure and the supply air velocity values were noted. By taking 100 set
of experiment readings the artificial neural network ANN was trained for the input
parameters and after subsequent training process the optimized fan speed was obtained.
Mathematical model
Polynomial model
The following form defines the model of the fan:
∆P n
2
P
0
+ k
1
m + k
2
m
2
…1
where ∆P – Pressure rise of the fan Pa.
n – Normalized rotational speed.
P
0
– Total pressure rise of the fan when the air flow rate equals zero.
m – The air flow rate and
k
1
k
2
– Constants.
Based on the characteristic curves of the fan the speed of the fan is a non- linear
function of the supply voltage of the motor. The following higher order polynomial is used
to express this non-linear function:
n
2
fv b
0
+ b
1
v + · · · + b
n
v
n
B
T
V …2
where v V/V
max
is the normalized value of the supply voltage.
slide 9: Int. J. Chem. Sci.: 14S2 2016 605
b
0
b
1
…… and b
n
are the coefficients.
B
T
b
0
b
1……
b
n
.
V 1 v v
2
……. v
n
T
.
The characteristic curves of the fan are represented by a polynomial with the
estimated coefficients. By substituting Eq. 1 to Eq. 2 the following form is expressed as:
∆P P
0
⎟
⎟
⎠
⎞
⎜
⎜
⎝
⎛
∑
n
1 i
i
biv
k
1
m + k
2
m
2
…3
The unknown coefficients are linear with respect to the measured variables of v and
m. using the performance data provided by manufacturer.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
To optimize the fan speed the mathematical model for the corresponding fan is
solved and the fan performance curves are estimated. For various supply voltage and the
corresponding air flow rate the total pressure rise of the fan is obtained. Based on the Fig. 8
it is inferred that at lower airflow rates the airflow rate corresponding to total pressure rise
obtained from ANN model is similar to real performance curves. However at higher flow
rates the real curves deviate much from the polynomial model curves.
Fig. 8: Estimated fan performance curves for polynomial model
Fig. 9 illustrates influence of airflow rate corresponding to the total pressure rise is
slide 10: A. Senthilkumar et al.: Optimization of Fan Speed in…. 606
represented based on neural network analysis. From Fig. 9 it is observed that the deviation
occurred between the real curves and ANN model curves are substantially less which can be
used to predict the thermal comfort required inside the conditioned space.
Fig. 9: Estimated fan performance curves using neural network model
By training the input data in the neural network the performance curves are observed
to be very close to real curves. This yields the optimized fan speed.
Fig. 10: Variation of supply airflow rate
Fig. 10 represents that with the use of variable speed fan optimized by ANN the
supply airflow rate is varied for the corresponding load fluctuation persisting in the
conditioned space. This infers that a substantial quantity of fan energy can be saved since the
fan is operated at its optimized speed.
slide 11: Int. J. Chem. Sci.: 14S2 2016 607
CONCLUSION
The fan speed was optimized using artificial neural network with input parameters of
supply voltage and airflow rate. An experimental analysis was performed to validate the
results obtained from ANN model curves to correlate with the real curves of supply air fan.
From the results it was evident that controlling the fan speed in accordance with the load
fluctuations well satisfies the thermal comfort required in the conditioned space of the
building envelope. Implementation of artificial neural network leads to quick and precise
optimization results.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The author would like to acknowledge the CPDE Anna University for supporting
this project work. Special thanks go to Dr. S. Iniyan Dr. D. Mohan Lal Mr. R.
Karunakaran Anna University.
REFERENCES
1. B. E. Abdullalif and M. A. Mahmoud Energy Conservation in Buildings Through
Efficient A/C Control Using Neural Networks Applied Energy 5-23 2002.
2. D. J. Swider M. W Browne P. K Bansal and V. Kecman Modeling of Vapor-
Compression Liquid Chillers with Neural Networks Appl. Thermal Engg. 311-329
2001.
3. D. J. Moschandreas and S. W. Choi Indoor Air Quality and the Variable-Air-
Volume/Bypass Filtration System: Chamber Experiment Pergamon 149-158 1996.
4. Erik Jeannette Experimental Results of a Predictive Neural Network HVAC
Controller ASHRAE Transactions 192-197 1998.
5. Haruro Uehara Visakhak K. Nanayakkara and Yasuyuki Ikegambi Evolutionary
Design of Dynamic Neural Networks for Evaporator Control Int. J. Refrigeration
813-826 2002.
6. Jin Wen and Theodore F. Smith Development and Validation of Online Models with
Parameter Estimation for a Building Zone with VAV System Energy and Buildings
2006.
7. K. S. Maki VAV System Performance-Field Characterization of Airflow System
Diagnosis Tools and Operational Design Implications ASHRAE Transaction 830-
841 1998.
slide 12: A. Senthilkumar et al.: Optimization of Fan Speed in…. 608
8. M. Hosoz Artificial Neural Network Analysis of an Automobile Air Conditioning
System 1574-1587 2006.
9. Mehmet Azmi Aktacir Orhan Buyukalaca and Tunacy Yilmaz Life Cycle Cost
Analysis for Constant-Air-Volume and Variable-Air-Volume Air-Conditioning
Systems Applied Energy 2005.
10. O. Ahmed Feed forward-Feedback Controller Using General Regression Neural
Network GRNN for Laboratory HVAC System: Part II – Temperature Control-
Cooling ASHRAE Transactions 626-634 1998.
11. S. Deng and W. Chen Development of a Dynamic Model for a DX VAV air
Conditioning System Energy Conservation and Management 2900-2924 2006.
12. S. A. Kalogiru Applications of Artificial Neural Network for Energy Systems
Applied Energy 17-35 2002.
13. Tuncay Tanyolu A Neural Network Approach with Self-Organized Principal
Component Analysis for Identification of Dehumidifying Coils ASHRAE
Transaction 96-102 1995.
Accepted : 01.07.2016