Presentation Transcript
TEEN SEX IN THE BLUFF CITY: TEEN SEX IN THE BLUFF CITY CENTER FOR RESEARCH ON WOMEN, U OF M
12/1/05
NANCY HARDT MD, UT
CONTACT INFORMATION: CONTACT INFORMATION NANCY HARDT, MD
UNIVERSITY OF TENNESSEE HEALTH SCIENCE CENTER
BEEPER: 1-888-961-8912
INTRODUCTION: INTRODUCTION TEEN SYSTEM FORMATION
TEEN SEXUALITY
YOUTH BEHAVIORAL RISK FACTOR SURVEY FOR MEMPHIS
TEEN PREGNANCY
SEXUALLY TRANSMITTED DISEASES
RECOMMENDATIONS
ADOLESCENT LOGIC: ADOLESCENT LOGIC BEHAVIORS ADULTS CHARACTERIZE AS SELF-DESTRUCTIVE SEEM LOGICAL TO THE ADOLESCENT
BEHAVIORS ARE THE NATURAL OUTCOMES OF THE PERSONAL HISTORY, SENSE OF SELF, AND DAY TO DAY REALITIES OF THAT ADOLESCENT
SOME OF THESE CONDITIONS FORM THEIR “SYSTEM”: SOME OF THESE CONDITIONS FORM THEIR 'SYSTEM' FEAR OF ABANDONMENT BY THEIR MOTHER
ABSENSE OF PROTECTIVE FATHER OR FATHER SURROGATE
LACK OF CONSISTENT GUIDANCE BY AN ADULT
FEW POSITIVE ROLE MODELS
INADEQUATE INFORMATION
ELEMENTS OF OUR SYSTEM: ELEMENTS OF OUR SYSTEM HOME ENVIRONMENT
MEDIA INFLUENCE
PEER INFLUENCE
SCHOOL AS A SOURCE OF INFORMATION
CHURCH AS A SOURCE OF INFORMATION, GUIDANCE, AND SUPPORT
MEDIA PORTRAYS TEENS AS SEXUAL BEINGS: MEDIA PORTRAYS TEENS AS SEXUAL BEINGS IF WE CAN’T CHANGE MEDIA INFLUENCE, WE MUST ARM TEENS WITH INFORMATION
ORAL SEX IS A BIG PART OF TEEN SEXUAL LIVES
TEENS AND ORAL SEX: TEENS AND ORAL SEX MOST TEENS DO NOT CONSIDER ORAL SEX THE SAME AS SEX
(DID THEY GET THIS IDEA FROM ADULTS?)
2002 NATIONAL SURVEY OF FAMILY GROWTH: 2002 NATIONAL SURVEY OF FAMILY GROWTH 10,000 TEENS SURVEYED
CDC CONDUCTED THE SURVEY
ORAL SEX MORE COMMON AMONG TEENS THAN SEXUAL INTERCOURSE
TEENS AND ORAL SEX: TEENS AND ORAL SEX 54% OF TEEN GIRLS, 55% TEEN BOYS HAVE HAD ORAL SEX
¼ OF TEENS WHO HAVE NOT HAD INTERCOURSE HAVE HAD ORAL SEX
LIKELIHOOD INCREASES WITH AGE: 42% 15-17 YEAR OLD GIRLS HAD ORAL SEX, 72% 18-19 YEAR OLD GIRLS
TEENS WHO HAVE NOT HAD INTERCOURSE GIVE REASONS FOR ORAL SEX: TEENS WHO HAVE NOT HAD INTERCOURSE GIVE REASONS FOR ORAL SEX 19% GIVE RELIGIOUS OR MORAL REASONS TO AVOID INTERCOURSE, YET THEY HAVE HAD ORAL SEX
38% SAID THE TIME WAS NOT RIGHT FOR SEXUAL INTERCOURSE, YET THEY HAD HAD ORAL SEX
TEEN SEXUAL NETWORKS: TEEN SEXUAL NETWORKS CHAINS OF AFFECTION: THE STRUCTURE OF ADOLESCENT ROMANTIC AND SEXUAL NETWORKS
DATA FROM THE NATIONAL LONGITUDINAL STUDY OF ADOLESCENT HEALTH (ADDHEALTH)
BEARMAN, MOODY, STOVEL, AM.J.SOCIOLOGY VOL110 NO1, JULY04:44-91
Slide13:
LOST CHILDREN OF ROCKDALE COUNTY: LOST CHILDREN OF ROCKDALE COUNTY ATLANTA SUBURB
CHILDREN ENGAGING IN GROUP SEX
SYPHILIS OUTBREAK
Slide15:
TENNESSEE DATA: TENNESSEE DATA HIGH SCHOOL OF 300
OUTBREAK OF TEEN GONORRHEA
26 TEENS IN SEXUAL NETWORK RANGING IN AGE FROM 15-18, 11 ADULTS (19-30)
10 INFECTED FEMALES
8 INFECTED MALES
FIVE MALES HAD SEX WITH INFECTED WOMEN BUT WERE (-)
Slide17: females males Red = Positive
Green = Negative
Yellow = Untested/Unknown
ASSOCIATION BETWEEN ADVERSE CHILDHOOD EXPERIENCES AND ADOLESCENT PREGNANCY: ASSOCIATION BETWEEN ADVERSE CHILDHOOD EXPERIENCES AND ADOLESCENT PREGNANCY HILLIS, ET AL. PEDIATRICS 2004
KAISER PERMANENTE INSURED
WERE PREGNANT BETWEEN AGES 11-19
77% WHITE AND 72% ATTENDED COLLEGE
8 RISK FACTORS: 8 RISK FACTORS EMOTIONAL ABUSE
PHYSICAL ABUSE
SEXUAL ABUSE
OBSERVED MOTHER AS VICTIM
HOUSEHOLD SUBSTANCE ABUSE
HOUSEHOLD MENTAL ILLNESS
HOUSEHOLD MEMBER INCARCERATED
PARENTAL SEPARATION OR DIVORCE
RISK : RISK ANY ONE OF THE EIGHT INCREASES RISK
RISKS ARE ADDITIVE
IF NO RISK FACTORS, 16% (NOT PER THOUSAND) BECOME PREGNANT
IF EIGHT RISK FACTORS, 53% BECOME PREGNANT
THE RESULTS: THE RESULTS THE PERCENT OF GIRLS WHO BECOME PREGNANT BY THE AGE OF 19 IS HIGHER IN THE US THAN ELSEWHERE
TEEN PARENTS ARE MORE LIKELY TO DROP OUT OF SCHOOL, HAVE MINIMUM WAGE JOBS, AND REMAIN ON PUBLIC ASSISTANCE
Slide22:
Slide23:
THE CHILDREN OF TEEN PARENTS: THE CHILDREN OF TEEN PARENTS ARE LESS LIKELY TO BE HEALTHY
ARE LESS LIKELY TO ENTER SCHOOL READY TO LEARN
ARE LESS LIKELY TO READ AT GRADE LEVEL
ARE LESS LIKELY TO GRADUATE FROM HIGH SCHOOL
ARE LESS LIKELY TO BE SELF-SUFFICIENT
WHY THESE OUTCOMES FOR TEEN PARENTS?: WHY THESE OUTCOMES FOR TEEN PARENTS? TEENS ARE STILL DEVELOPING THEIR SENSE OF 'SELF'
THEY ARE INWARDLY FOCUSED
FOR THEM TO FOCUS ON AN INFANT IS NOT IMPOSSIBLE, BUT REQUIRES ADDITIONAL SUPPORT
IF THEY HAD THAT SUPPORT, THEY WOULD BE LESS LIKELY TO BE TEEN PARENTS
Slide26:
TEEN CONFIDENTIALITY: TEEN CONFIDENTIALITY 13 Y/O ARE EMANCIPATED MINORS WHEN SEXUALLY ACTIVE
IF LESS THAN 13, REPORTABLE CHILD ABUSE IF SEXUALLY ACTIVE
NO PARENTAL PERMISSION NEEDED TO TEST OR TREAT
CHILD HAS RIGHT TO CONFIDENTIALITY
Slide28:
YOUTH RISK FOR HIV (ST. JUDE DATA): YOUTH RISK FOR HIV (ST. JUDE DATA) MEAN AGE 17 FOR ADOLESCENTS WITH HIV WHO GOT IT THROUGH SEX
49% FEMALES HAD BEEN SEXUALLY ABUSED
30% ABANDONED OR NEGLECTED BY PARENTS
46% PARENTAL SUBSTANCE ABUSE
41% JUVENILE DETENTION
RISK FOR HIV IN MEMPHIS YOUTH: RISK FOR HIV IN MEMPHIS YOUTH 52% REPORTED 3 OR MORE SEX PARTNERS
20% DISCOVERED HIV AT TIME OF TEEN PREGNANCY
60% REPORTED PRIOR STI
DATA SUMMARY: DATA SUMMARY WHEN IT COMES TO RISKS, OUR CHILDREN ARE VULNERABLE (EARLY SEX, MULTIPLE PARTNERS, FORCED SEX, DATING VIOLENCE, NOT USING CONTRACEPTION)
WHEN IT COMES TO PROTECTIONS, OUR CHILDREN ARE LACKING (HIV EDUCATION, CONTRACEPTION)
HOW WELL CONDOMS WORK: HOW WELL CONDOMS WORK DO NOT ADD TO DISINFORMATION
REFERENCE: CONTRACEPTIVE TECHNOLOGY
COMPARE DATA ON VARIOUS CONTRACEPTIVE METHODS
THEIR SUCCESS WITH PERFECT USE: THEIR SUCCESS WITH PERFECT USE ABSTINENCE 100%
MIRENA 99.9%
STERILIZATION 99.5%
PILL 99.7%
CONDOMS 98 %
DIAPHRAGM 94%
NO METHOD 15%
WITH IMPERFECT USE: WITH IMPERFECT USE ABSTINENCE GOES TO THE BOTTOM OF THE LIST
PILLS, CONDOMS, DIAPHRAGMS WORK 85%
CONDOMS FOR STI: CONDOMS FOR STI EFFECTIVENESS DEPENDS ON TWO THINGS:
IS THE RIGHT ORIFICE COVERED?
DOES THE TRANSMISSION OF THE DISEASE REQUIRE MUCOUS MEMBRANE TO MUCOUS MEMBRANE CONTACT?
(CONTRAST LOW RISK AND HIGH RISK HPV)
Slide36:
THE FOLLOWING DEPEND ON MUCOUS TO MUCOUS MEMBRANE CONTACT: THE FOLLOWING DEPEND ON MUCOUS TO MUCOUS MEMBRANE CONTACT PREGNANCY
GONORRHEA
HIV
CHLAMYDIA
SYPHILIS
HIGH RISK HPV
YOUTH RISK BEHAVIORAL SURVEILLANCE SURVEY: YOUTH RISK BEHAVIORAL SURVEILLANCE SURVEY 2003
YOUTH RISK BEHAVIORAL SURVEILLANCE SURVEY: YOUTH RISK BEHAVIORAL SURVEILLANCE SURVEY
SCHOOL BASED SURVEY
IN CONJUNCTION WITH THE CENTERS FOR DISEASE CONTROL
IN ALL STATES
IN SELECTED URBAN AREAS
PURPOSE OF YRBSS: PURPOSE OF YRBSS IDENTIFY LEADING CAUSES OF MORBIDITY AND MORTALITY
THESE ARE INTERRELATED AND PREVENTABLE
POLICIES AND PROGRAMS CAN ADDRESS THESE RISKS
MEMPHIS YRBSS DATA 2003: MEMPHIS YRBSS DATA 2003 MEMPHIS 2005 DATA NOT YET RELEASED
STATE DATA 2005 INCLUDES MEMPHIS DATA
2003 DATA FOR 9-12 GRADES, BOYS AND GIRLS
COMPARE PINK/BLUE BARS FOR SEX DIFFERENCE
COMPARE LAST 4 BARS FOR AGE DIFFERENCE
2003 ORANGE BARS: 2003 ORANGE BARS COMPARE MEMPHIS 2003 DATA TO OTHER SOUTHERN URBAN AREAS AND THE US
Slide43:
Slide44:
Slide45:
Slide46:
Slide47:
Slide48:
Slide49:
Slide50:
Slide51:
Slide52:
Slide53:
Slide54:
Slide55:
Slide56:
Slide57:
Slide58:
Slide59:
Slide60:
Slide61:
Slide62:
2003-2005 CHANGES IN FEMALES--TN: 2003-2005 CHANGES IN FEMALES--TN 47 NOW 55% EVER HAD SEX
36 NOW 41% SEX IN LAST 3 MONTHS
12 NOW 15% SEX WITH MORE THAN 4
9 NOW 11% DATING VIOLENCE
13 NOW 15% FORCED TO HAVE SEX
4 NOW 13% SEX BEFORE 13
90 NOW 91% TAUGHT HIV IN SCHOOL
YEAR TO YEAR CHANGE…: YEAR TO YEAR CHANGE… 48 NOW 30% USED CONDOM LAST TIME
17 NOW 11% USED BCP
DISTURBING NEWS: DISTURBING NEWS SEX IS INITIATED EARLIER
MONOGAMY IS NOT PRACTICED
LESS CONDOM PROTECTION (LESS FEAR OF AIDS?)
WE UNDERESTIMATE EXPOSURE BY NOT INCLUDING ORAL SEX IN THE CATEGORY OF SEXUAL ACTIVITY
RECOMMENDATIONS: RECOMMENDATIONS THINK OF ALL CHILDREN AS SEXUAL BEINGS (THE MARKET DOES!)
UNHEALTHY RELATIONSHIPS REMOVE CHOICE-WARN THEM, GIVE EXAMPLES
ABSTINENCE IS THE BEST OPTION
MAKE SURE THE DEFINITION OF ABSTINENCE INCLUDES ORAL AND ANAL SEX!
RECOMMENDATIONS: RECOMMENDATIONS THEY MUST HAVE A BACKUP PLAN IN PLACE BEFORE ABSTINENCE IS OVER
CONDOMS WORK WELL IF THEY ARE USED EVERY TIME AND THEY ARE APPLIED AND REMOVED CORRECTLY
NON 'INTERCOURSE' SEX IS NOT SAFE SEX
RECOMMENDATIONS: RECOMMENDATIONS HAVE KIDS ANSWER THESE:
WHAT FACTS DO THEY WANT?
WHAT INFO WOULD THEY USE?
WHO SHOULD DELIVER INFO?
WHAT MEDIA WOULD APPEAL (DRAMA, MUSIC, POSTERS, PSA)?
RECOMMENDATIONS: RECOMMENDATIONS START DISCUSSIONS OF RISKS OF SEX IN MIDDLE SCHOOL (STATE CURRICULUM REVIEW? )
URINE SCREEN FOR CHLAMYDIA/GONORRHEA AS 'GATEWAY' STI, AND HAVE SPECIAL INTERVENTION TO PREVENT HIV IN THOSE TESTING POSITIVE