sara 090402

Uploaded from authorPOINTLite
Views:
 
Category: Education
     
 

Presentation Description

No description available.

Comments

Presentation Transcript

“A non-biological Origin for the Nano- phase Magnetite Grains in ALH84001: Experimental Results” (Koziol & Brearley, Lunar and Planetary Science XXXIII, 2002) : 

“A non-biological Origin for the Nano- phase Magnetite Grains in ALH84001: Experimental Results” (Koziol & Brearley, Lunar and Planetary Science XXXIII, 2002) Sara Bergenius sarabe@particle.kth.se Martian meteorite ALH84001 A potato

Life on Mars?: 

Life on Mars? In 1996 McKay et al. announced possible evidence of ancient life on Mars. A Martian meteorite showed ~3 billion years old remnants of organic molecules. Sara Bergenius sarabe@particle.kth.se

ALH84001: 

ALH84001 Martian origin: unique composition of oxygen isotopes consistent with Martian atmosphere. Three ages: 4.5 billion years old (oldest of Martian meteorites) 16 million years in space 13000 years on earth No terrestrial weathering. Carbon isotopic composition different from weathered meteorites. Sara Bergenius sarabe@particle.kth.se

Martians=Carbonate pancakes?: 

Martians=Carbonate pancakes? Sara Bergenius sarabe@particle.kth.se Tubes and ovoids, ~10-100 nm. Regions of debate: Carbonate globules, ~1-250 μm. McKay has three arguments:

Mini Martians?: 

Mini Martians? Sara Bergenius sarabe@particle.kth.se Magnetites, ~1-100nm, in rims of carbonate pancakes. High concentration of PAH (Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons) in carbonate areas.

Synthetic Martians?: 

Synthetic Martians? Andrea Koziol reproduced non-biological grains similar to the ones in ALH84001. Same size, same shape, same slanted edges and same lined-up atoms as in the meteorite. Method: heat synthetic carbonates to 470ºC for 5 min  voilà magnetite. But, this does not discount the “Life on Mars” theory. Sara Bergenius sarabe@particle.kth.se

Summary: 

Summary Are the magnetite crystals remnants of magnetotactical bacteria? Strong magnetic field on early Mars? 5 out of 6 criterias are fulfilled. Extraordinary claims requires extraordinary evidence. Sara Bergenius sarabe@particle.kth.se