downs session6

Mosquito Control In California – Is It Working?: 

Mosquito Control In California – Is It Working? Craig Downs, General Manager Contra Costa Mosquito & Vector Control District

Origins of mosquito control in California: 

Origins of mosquito control in California From California Folklore… “In the Gold Rush period, mosquitoes in the San Francisco area wore pants made from the sails of ships lying idle in the Bay. On the east coast, sailors did not mind the Jersey mosquitoes, but whenever they were attacked by mosquitoes wearing sailcloth pants, there was panic aboard, for the sailors recognized them as roving bands of mosquitoes from San Francisco.”

Origins of mosquito control in California - 1915: 

Origins of mosquito control in California - 1915 Many historical accounts state that areas of the SF Bay Area were often uninhabitable First mosquito abatement district was established in Marin Co., in 1915, to combat salt marsh mosquitoes, followed closely by San Mateo Co. in 1916

Origins of mosquito control in California - 1917: 

Origins of mosquito control in California - 1917 Another mosquito abatement district was formed in Bakersfield to control endemic malaria Two more districts were formed in the Northern Sacramento Valley; Tehama Co. in 1917 and Shasta Co. in 1919

Origins of mosquito control in California - 1930: 

Origins of mosquito control in California - 1930 In the summer of 1930, a major epizootic of encephalomyelitis developed in horses in the San Joaquin Valley (WEE) Another twelve districts were formed in the 20’s and 30’s

Legislative Intent origin 1915, rev’d 2002: 

Legislative Intent origin 1915, rev’d 2002 H&SC Section 2001 recognizes that: California’s climate and topography supports the development of human disease vectors and nuisance pests. Some vector-borne diseases may be fatal. California’s international connections increase the opportunity for vector and disease introductions. WNV and the Asian Tiger Mosquito are specifically identified as recent introductions.

Legislative Intent: 

Legislative Intent H&SC Section 2001 declares that: Personal protection against mosquitoes is only partially effective. Protection is best achieved by organized public programs. Protection against vector borne diseases is an essential service that is vital to public health Mosquito abatement and vector control districts have served this role starting in 1915.

Goal of Mosquito Control: 

Goal of Mosquito Control To maintain populations of mosquitoes and other vectors at “acceptable levels” (thresholds) within a geographic area or region to prevent disease transmission to maintain the quality of life for the members of the community

Integrated Pest Management: 

Integrated Pest Management IPM is an ecosystem-based strategy which focuses on long term prevention of mosquito-borne disease and damage through a combination of physical, biological and chemical methods Our goal is not to eradicate mosquitoes but to keep the population below levels that affect public health Pesticides are used when surveillance indicates they are necessary, and treatments are made with the goal of reducing mosquitoes while minimizing risks to people, wildlife, and the environment

IPM: Basic components: 

IPM: Basic components Surveillance Treatment thresholds Control Habitat manipulation Water management practices Biological Chemical, including a pesticide resistance management component Training and certification Compliance with environmental regulations

Encephalitis virus Surveillance: 

Encephalitis virus Surveillance Sentinel chickens tested for antibodies twice monthly May-October Mosquito samples (500 per site) tested weekly July-October Dead birds tested in-house and sent to DHS for confirmation Part of statewide surveillance network coordinated by CDHS/VBDS

Larval control: 

Larval control Larval control preferred Choice of method based on: Habitat Species/life stages present Population density Nuisance/disease potential Presence/absence of natural predators Presence/absence of sensitive species Water conditions

 Larval control: 

Larval control We use a combination of methods: Source reduction (eliminating the water or restoring natural flow) Biological control: mosquito-eating fish Pesticides Biological larvicides Insect growth regulator Larvicidal oils Monomolecular surface film Organophosphate Mosquito larvae mosquitofish ATV spray operation

How do we know treatments are effective for larval control?: 

How do we know treatments are effective for larval control? Visual inspection Pre and post treatment larval dipping counts Emergent jars (insect growth regulator only)

Controlling adult mosquitoes: 

Controlling adult mosquitoes When larval control is not possible or has been used to the fullest extent possible, adult mosquito control may be required to suppress populations Once there are adult mosquitoes in an area, killing larvae will not reduce biting or disease transmission. Truck mounted ULV application

Controlling adult mosquitoes: 

Controlling adult mosquitoes Adult mosquito control products may be applied either using ground-based equipment, fixed wing airplanes, or helicopters. Available products include natural pyrethrins and synthetic pyrethroids, such as resmethrin, sumithrin, and permethrin; and the organophosphates, malathion and naled.

Ground-based (vehicle mounted)adult mosquito control operations: 

Ground-based (vehicle mounted)adult mosquito control operations Where road access is adequate, such as in urban and suburban residential areas, good coverage may be achieved. Applications can be done throughout the night, thereby targeting night-active mosquito species. Applications are prone to skips and patchy coverage in areas where road coverage is not adequate or in which the habitat contains significant barriers to spray dispersal and penetration. http://www.cdc.gov/ncidod/dvbid/westnile/resources/wnv-guidelines-aug-2003.pdf

Aircraft-based adult mosquito control operations: 

Aircraft-based adult mosquito control operations Capable of covering larger areas in shorter time periods than a ground-based application. Less prone to patchy coverage than ground-based application in areas where road coverage is not adequate. http://www.cdc.gov/ncidod/dvbid/westnile/resources/wnv-guidelines-aug-2003.pdf

How do we know treatments are effective for adult control?: 

How do we know treatments are effective for adult control? Pre- and post spray vector mosquito densities inside and outside control area Landing counts Trap counts Caged mosquito Weather conditions during application (temperature, wind speed, direction).

2004 California Activities: 

2004 California Activities 53 member agencies comprise MVCAC Majority incorporate adult control w/ efficacy component Various suburban/urban areas throughout state sprayed (ultra low volume) without any reported incidents

Environmental compliance: 

Environmental compliance Comply with FIFRA, CWA, and CEQA regulations Report pesticide usage to County Dept. of Agriculture and Regional Water Resources Control Board Subject to inspections by Agriculture Department Operate under M.O.U. with California Dept. of Health Services which also administers certification and training

Pesticide Use for Mosquito Control – Safety Record: 

Pesticide Use for Mosquito Control – Safety Record No reported pesticide exposure related cases in CA 2003 – 2004. pers. com. Dr. V. Kramer, Chief, Vector-Borne Disease Section, CA DHS. Surveillance for Acute Insecticide-Related Illness Associated with Mosquito-Control Efforts – Nine States, 1999-2002 CDC, Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report, July 11, 2003/52(27);629-634.

Slide23: 

The findings in this report indicate that serious adverse outcomes potentially related to public health insecticide application were uncommon. When administered properly in a mosquito-control program, insecticides pose a low risk for acute, temporary health effects among persons in areas that are being sprayed and among workers handling and applying insecticides. Dr. Arthur L. Craigmill, Extension Toxicologist reports in the September 2003 issue of Environmental Toxicology Newsletter, Cooperative Extension, University of California, Davis

Pesticide Environmental Stewardship Program: 

Pesticide Environmental Stewardship Program Administered through U.S. EPA American Mosquito Control Association member since May 1996 Mosquito and Vector Control Association of CA is one of seven state and regional associations that participate through AMCA

Pesticide Environmental Stewardship Program: 

Pesticide Environmental Stewardship Program a voluntary program that forms partnerships with pesticide users to reduce the health and environmental risks associated with pesticide use and implement pollution prevention strategies

Pesticide Environmental Stewardship Program – AMCA 2004 goals: 

Pesticide Environmental Stewardship Program – AMCA 2004 goals Public lands – IPM CE programs for mosquito control workers Public Education programs Proper surveillance for effective, targeted responses

Slide30: 

FEB MAR APR MAY JUNE JULY AUG SEP OCT NOV

Importance of WNV Dead Bird Surveillance Program: 

Importance of WNV Dead Bird Surveillance Program Dead bird surveillance was important for early WNV detection Earliest indication of WNV activity in 91% (53/58) of California counties in 2004 Dead bird surveillance system widely used by public / education tool Dead bird reports also gave an indication of WNV activity

Slide32: 

Importance continued Only surveillance element that covered ALL 58 counties Mosquito pool and sentinel chicken testing limited to only those areas with established mosquito control programs. There were 22 counties that had dead birds as the only evidence of WNV activity in 2004.

In Summary: 

In Summary Mosquito control agencies have been effectively protecting public health for many years; WNV has brought programs back to forefront California has a comprehensive mosquito-borne disease surveillance program that has monitored mosquito abundance and mosquito-borne virus activity since 1969 Public’s continued ability to work and enjoy the outdoors with very low incidence of disease is testimony of programs success

Slide36: 

MVCAC 660 J Street, Suite 480 Sacramento, CA 95814 (916) 440-0826 Mvcac@mvcac.org www.mvcac.org Chris Voight - Executive Director

How toxic are the pesticides we use?: 

How toxic are the pesticides we use?