slide 1: Fitriana R et al / Int. J. of Allied Med. Sci. and Clin. Research Vol-63 2018 654-661
654
IJAMSCR |Volume 6 | Issue 3 | July - Sep - 2018
www.ijamscr.com
Research article Medical research
The combination of dark chocolate and spiritual emotional freedom
technique SEFT towards anxiety level and blood pressure on primigravida
pregnancy women
Fitriana Rakhimah
1
Diyah Fatmasari
2
Suryati Kumorowulan
3
1
College Student Poltekkes Kemenkes Semarang Semarang Indonesia
2 3
College teacher Poltekkes Kemenkes Semarang Semarang Indonesia
Jl.Tirto Agung Pedalangan Banyumanik Semarang
Corresponding Author: Fitriana Rakhimah
Email id: fitrianarakhimah6gmail.com
ABSTRACT
Background
The climax of anxiety level happens on third trimester when the pregnancy is on week 32-36 due to fake and real
contraction. Anxiety can be reduced by giving dark chocolate as chocolate induces comfort and calmness while
SEFT makes blood stream smooth. The combination of both therapy has never been done before. The objective of
this research is to analyze the effect of combination of dark chocolate and spiritual emotional freedom technique
SEFT towards anxiety level and blood pressure on primigravida pregnancy in Bumijawa Community Health Center
working area.
Method
The design of this research was Quasi experimental using pre and post test with control group approach. The
population was 256 women on primigravida pregnancy with simple random sampling was used as sampling
technique. 50 gr/day of chocolate were given everyday at 16.00 and 18 points SEFT therapy was given for 20
minutes/day. Questioner was used to measure anxiety and sphygmomanometer and oximeter were used to measure
vital sign mann whitneywilcoxson test and linear regression test were used on statistical analysis.
Result
The result of pre-post group is p 0001 which means there is an effect of dark chocolate consumption and SEFT
therapy towards anxiety level and blood pressure on primigravida pregnancy. Then wilcoxson test was used to
compare groups resulting significance level 0000 ≤ 005 which means on dark chocolate and SEFT therapy group is
more effective in reducing anxiety and reducing blood pressure on primigravida pregnancy.
Conclusion
A combination of dark chocolate and SEFT therapy is more affecting to reduce anxiety to reduce blood pressure
compared to dark chocolate.
Keywords: Anxiety Primigravida Pregnancy Blood PressureChocolate Consumption SEFT Therapy
ISSN:2347-6567
International Journal of Allied Medical Sciences
and Clinical Research IJAMSCR
slide 2: Fitriana R et al / Int. J. of Allied Med. Sci. and Clin. Research Vol-63 2018 654-661
655
INTRODUCTION
First pregnancy is really important for women
compared to subsequence pregnancies. On first
pregnancy women tend to feel anxiety fear worry
mixed with happiness. Pregnant women feel
anxious on their pregnancy birth period and
tiredness. The happiness occurs when neighbours
and friends congratulate them and pray for their
pregnancy. As the pregnancy grows old the
thought and attention of pregnant women are
getting fixed on something climatic resulting on
feeling of restless and worry is getting more
intensive as the pregnancy is approaching due day.
The worry of approaching giving birth is ranked
first of negative feelings underwent by women
during pregnancy
1.
In Indonesia during 2013 there were 107.000
pregnant women 287 who felt anxious in
approaching giving birth
2. The data from Public
Health Service of Tegal district shows that there
were 29.833 pregnant women in 2016. Among
them there were 26.923 9025 categorized as
K4. In 2017 there were 29.232 pregnant women
with 20.309 6948 of them categorized as K4.
The causes of anxiety are threat of body mind
or mental different wants of contrastive nature
unfulfilled needs which all lead to anxiety. Fear of
something also contributes to anxiety for instance
the fear of failure in giving birth
1.
Other negative impacts of excesscive anxiety
on pregnant women are premature birth and even
miscarriage
3. A certain research also shows that
the above condition will rise the risk of
hypertension. Hypertension could lead to stroke
seizure or even death to both mother and her fetus.
If this keeps happening the mortality and
morbidity number will increase
4.
To this date pharmacological therapy most of
the time will have side effects which are
dangerous for pregnant women. The examples of
drugs used on psychopharmacology therapy
include anti-anxiety anxiolytic like diazepam
chlordiazepxide HCL oxazolam hydroxine HCL
and rhizome. There is also anti-depresant like
fluoksetin paroksetin antipsychotics
proklorpezin arisiolitik benzodiepin whose
side effects for pregnant women include anorexia
nausea diarrhea constipation digestive system
disorder change of heart pulse and the more
dangerous bleeding and the lacking production of
prolactin
5. Meanwhile non-pharmacological
therapies commonly used for reducing anxiety are
cognitive therapy metacognitive therapy efficacy
therapy yoga and prayer
6.
A study of the use of dark chocolate to reduce
anxiety level on teenagers was done by Laveda
Jesylin by using HARS scale reducing mild-
anxiety of 148 to non-anxiety 59 which can be
concluded as effective in reducing anxiety
7.
Another study by Laily 2016 also showed that
there was a reduction of anxiety from medium-
anxiety to mild-anxiety even though it was not
considered effective yet as the patients still felt
anxious
8.
It is also strengthened by the result of study of
Kristanto and Wong Sy that pregnant women
feeling anxiety will raise the level of adrenaline
and norepinephrine or epinephrine and
norepinephrine causing deregulations of body
biochemistry. Consuming chocolate can increase
happiness and improve body condition. Some
people believe that the oro-sencoric-ness of
chocolate is the main factor of regulating mood
because chocolate contains phenethylamine which
triggers the release of endorphine. It is also known
that chocolate contains substance that can subs
glutamate to reduce depression/anxiety 9 10
Preliminary survey done on November 6 2017
showed that there were 1112 pregnant women in
Bumijawa Community Health Center working
area. Among them 256 were on Trimester III
during February – March of 2018. Then 8
respondents were randomly chosen and later
interviewed. 5 out of 8 respondents revealed that
they were feeling anxious because it was their first
pregnancy and were worried of giving birth. The
other 2 respondents were feeling less anxious
because they said that they had read books about
pregnancy. It can be concluded that there were
many primigravida pregnant women on TM III
who felt anxious in approaching their giving birth
time. Moreover those 8 respondents were asked
about dark chocolate consumption tap therapy on
certain meridian points to regulate blood
circulation and prayer. They said they did not
know the function of chocolate consumption and
the knock therapy. In order to boost the reduction
slide 3: Fitriana R et al / Int. J. of Allied Med. Sci. and Clin. Research Vol-63 2018 654-661
656
of anxiety the researcher wanted to conduct
holistic care combined with dark chocolate
consumption and SEFT therapy expecting to boost
the effect size and reducing anxiety level further.
METHOD
Population and Sampling
Quasi Experimental design was used in this
research with pre and posttest with control group.
Two groups were chosen non-randomly
11. This
design was used to find out the effectiveness of
combining dark chocolate and SEFT therapy
towards anxiety level blood pressure and heart
pulse on primigravida pregnant women. The
research was done on Bumijawa Community
Health Center from February until March of 2018.
The population was 256 respondents of
primigravida pregnant women. Samples were
chosen from population based on the criteria of
primigravida pregnant women who were on 32-36
weeks feeling anxiety which were gathered
through interview. The symptoms of anxiety are
lack of sleep digestive system disorder bad mood
and traumatic experience. The formula of picking
sample for hypothesis testing with type 1 error is
1 96 5 type 2 error is 0842 80
11.
Standard deviation for experimental group was 2
34 and for the control group was 2 01. The
calculation showed that the minimum number of
sample was 58. Based on the above estimation this
research was using 60 samples which were divided
into experimental group and control group.
Treatment
Before conducting the research the researcher
proposed prior assessment ethics and research permit
then the similarity of perception between the
researcher the enumerator the determination of
subjects according to the inclusion criteria divided
into 2 groups the intervention group with the
provision of dark chocolate and SEFT therapy. Each
member of the experimental group was given dark
chocolate 50 gr diluted in warm water of 37 C as
much as 200 cc. 50 gr dark chocolate contain 3.3 mg
/ 50g Phenylethylamine PEA and amino acid
tryptophan phenylalanin and tyrosine 3.75 1415
mg of Flavonoid CAE/50 gr antioxidant 6.560
unit/50 gr Calcium Ca 321 Magnesium Mg
674 Iron Fe 245 12 13. It was given once
per day between 15.00 until 16.00 as 1 hour of pre
meal. Afterwards respondents were given SEFT
therapy of tapping on 18 meridian points for 20
minutes each day. This was done for 14 days
straight. The members control group was given the
same treatment of 14 days dark chocolate
consumption excluding the SEFT therapy.
The SEFT therapy was taught by certified
expert based on pre-made Standard Operating
Procedure. The respondents were evaluated
throughout the teaching process by the researcher.
Instrument
The instruments of this research include
observation sheet which was used during direct
observation on respondents to gather data about
anxiety sphygmomanometer to gather data of
blood pressure oximeter to get data of heart pulse.
Questionnaire based on BAIS scale Beck Anxiety
Inventory was used whose answers were using
Likert scale of 4 points of answers. They are “not
bothering at all” scoring 0 “not really bothering”
scoring 1 “sometimes bothering” scoring 2 and
“really bothering” scoring 3. The sum score were
then used to describe how badly the anxiety was
bothering the respondens on BAI scale. Score of 0-
7 means non anxious 8-15 means mildly anxious
16-25 means medium anxious and 26-63 means
heavily anxious. The validity of Beck Anxiety
Inventory BAI was in correlation with the level
of anxiety r 0 48
14 15
Data Analysis
The data of this research were analyzed by
using univariate and bivariate analysis. The
experimental group of dark chocolate and SEFT
therapy combination and the control group of dark
chocolate therapy were tested using mann whitney
to see the significance of difference between pre
and posttest. Wilcoxon test was then used to see
the difference between the two groups
experimental and control group.
Research Ethics
The research ethics of this study was given by
Health Research Ethics Commitee of Semarang
Health Polythechnic of Ministry of Health with
slide 4: Fitriana R et al / Int. J. of Allied Med. Sci. and Clin. Research Vol-63 2018 654-661
657
registration number No:
024/KEPK/Poltekkessmg/EC/2018.All respondents
involved in this research were given appropriate
information consent.
RESULT
The majority of respondent characteristics from
experimental and control group are shown in the
table 1.1. The average age is 24 years old.
Pregnancy age average is 33 weeks. 60 of
respondents are at least high school graduate. 73
3 of them are worker.
Table 1 - frequency distribution of respondents’ characteristics based on age education occupation and
pregnancy age in Bumijawa Community Health Center working area in 2018.
Variable Group ᵖ value
Experimental n30 Control n30
n Average ± SD n Average ± SD
Age years old 30 2437± 0999 30 2420 ± 0847 0168
Pregnancy Age 30 3327±1337 30 3327±1437 0595
Education
Higher Education
Medium and lower Education
n
12
18
40
60
n
16
14
533
467
0359
Occupation
Housewife
Worker
n
22
8
733
267
n
20
10
667
333
0273
Lavene test was used for testing homogeneity
with p 0 05. It means the data were
homogenous. It can be concluded that both groups
are similar.
Table 2 – frequency distribution of respondents’ characteristics based on BAI score blood pressure on systole
and diastole and heart pulse in Bumijawa Community Health Center working area in 2018.
Variable Group
Experimental Control
Pretest
Anxiety
Average ± SD 1820 ± 3662 1643 ± 3137
Min-max 11-25 11-22
Blood pressure on sistole
Average ± SD 134±3806 13383±3640
Min-max 130-140 130-140
Blood pressure on diastole
Average ± SD 8750±2862 8783±2520
Min-max 80-90 85-90
Post Test
Anxiety
Average ± SD 993 ± 3868 1247± 3340
Min-max 5-17 7-18
Blood pressure on sistole
Average ± SD 115± 5085 12183±6757
slide 5: Fitriana R et al / Int. J. of Allied Med. Sci. and Clin. Research Vol-63 2018 654-661
658
Min-max 110-120 110-135
Blood pressure on diastole
Average ± SD 73±3851 7733±6789
Min-max 70-85 70-90
The result of normality test on anxiety level
blood pressure on systole and blood pressure on
diastole all show the data are not normally
distributed 0 05. From table 2 we can quickly
identify that the average number of anxiety level
on pretest between experimental and control group
does not have really big difference averaging 2-3
points of different.
Moreover on posttest there is a reduction of
anxiety level especially on experimental group
compared to two control groups. Blood pressure
both on systole and diastole remains largely the
same for pretest and posttest. But there is also
more reduction of the number in experimental
group compared to the control group.
Table 3 – the effect of combination of dark chocolate consumption and SEFT therapy towards anxiety level
blood pressure and heart pulse on primigravida pregnant women posttest using mann whitney
Variable Mean square Z p-value
Anxiety level 294500 -2333 0020
Blood pressure on systole 217500 -3809 0000
Blood pressure on diastole 293000 -2642 0014
The result of mann whitney on posttest data
shows that the average number of anxiety 0 02
blood pressure on systole 0000 blood pressure
on diastole 0014. It means that there is
statistically significant effect of giving dark
chocolate and SEFT therapy.
Table 4 – the difference between experimental group and control group posttest using wilcoxon
Variable P value-Experimental P value- Control
Anxiety level 0000 0000
Blood pressure on systole 0000 0000
Blood pressure on diastole 0000 0000
From table 4 wilcoxon test shows that all
numbers of anxiety level blood pressure on
systole blood pressure on diastole are below 0005.
It can be concluded that there is significant
difference between experimental group and control
group.
Multivariate data analysis technique used in this
study with linear regression analysis which is used
to determine the effect of variable confounding
namely: age gestational age education and
employment on the dependent variable that is
anxiety level and systolic and diastolic blood
pressure.
Then the variable age gestational age
education and occupation showed no relationship
with the value of r 0.00-0.25 with p value 0.05
which means that counfonding variables do not
play a role in anxiety levels systolic or diastolic
blood pressure
DISCUSSION
The result of this research shows that there is a
significant effect of dark chocolate consumption
and SEFT therapy on anxiety level of primigravida
pregnant women.
The reduction of anxiety level is caused by
phenylethylamine and anadamine contained within
chocolate to stimulate the brain to produce
dophamine and release a large number of β-
endorphine which induces the feeling of happiness.
Another substance in chocolate is triptofan amino
acid which is related to the level of serotonin in the
brain
16
. Triptofan is a precursor serotonin
slide 6: Fitriana R et al / Int. J. of Allied Med. Sci. and Clin. Research Vol-63 2018 654-661
659
neurotransmiter which regulates mood and feelings
7 17
A previous research done by Laily Wahidatul
Oktavia revealed that on HARS scale medium
anxiety state was reduced to mild anxiety through
giving treatment. That result gave further proof that
chocolate could reduce anxiety level. The important
substance within chocolate had been broken down
through metabolism enabling nerve system to
manage and reduce anxiety level.
Pregnant woman having anxiety will have her
level of adrenaline and noradrenaline or
epinephrine and norepinephrine raised higher than
normal which will cause biochemistry
deregulations leading to physical tense on her body.
Previous research done earlier revealed that
consuming dark chocolate reduce anxiety level
from mildly anxious to non-anxious. In addition
yet another research gave result from medium
anxiety to non-anxiety
7.
A research conducted on respondents having
anxiety on medium level was done by Puspita
Dewi. SEFT therapy was given to the respondents
and measured using Zung Self-Rating Anxiety
Scale ZSAS
18. The result however showed
constant change of anxiety level. It is explained in
the theory provided by Ahmad Faiz Zainuddin that
there are 11 hindrances of successful SEFT
therapy. Among those reasons are: the lack of
knowledge and skill the lack of bodily fluid
dehydration spiritual-related hindrance
incertitude unwillingness less resigned lack of
focus and lack of gratitude psychological
resistance the feeling of indifference in doing set-
up and tune-in unidentified root of problem lack
of SEFT expert involvement uneager to change in
need of collarbone respiration and allergic to
certain substance which will hinder the process of
SEFT therapy
19. In conclusion the process of
SEFT therapy requires high concentration level and
seriousness in order for the anxiety level to be
reduced.
In regard to this matter the researcher ensures
that the combination of dark chocolate and SEFT
therapy is successful in reducing anxiety level it is
need to be noted that the giving of dark chocolate
must be routine and on appropriate dosage and that
the SEFT therapy must be done on high
concentration and seriousness.
The result of the research showed that there was
a reduction of 13 13 from 87 80 before treatments
and 74 67 post treatments.
Laveda Jesyylin’s research showed that the
mean of before treatments was 88 8 and post
treatments was 77 9. There was 10 9 reduction. In
this case the combination of dark chocolate
consumption and SEFT therapy is successful in
reducing heart pulse when compared to treatments
using only dark chocolate consumption. The reason
is dark chocolate and SEFT therapy combination
can fix blood flow dilated system the measurement
showed artery blood vessel became relaxed and
thus accelerated blood flow
7 20.
The average of blood pressure on systole of
experimental group is reduced from 134 before
treatments to 115 post treatments meaning there
is 19 reduction. Meanwhile for blood pressure on
diastole there is a reduction of 14 5 from 875
mmHg to 73 mmHg between before treatments and
post treatments.
The result of Laveda Jesylin’s research showed
the systolic pressure was 111 9 reduced to 1081
and diastolic pressure was 714 to 703 through
treatments
7
. When feeling anxious the blood
pressure and heart pulse of pregnant women tends
to rise. On pregnant women it is considered rising
if it is 120 mmHg – 80 mmHg. The respondents
were on normal blood pressure. Data collecting was
not on appropriate category and chocolate was
given as much as 50 gr for 3 days.
A research done in Carolina also revealed that
consuming chocolate throughout 15 days can
reduce blood pressure on systole and diastole on
those who are healthy young old or even having
hypertension
8
. It is expected that the increasing of
NO bioavailability flavanol which induces
inhibition of angiotensin converting ezime and
stearic acid which reduces blood pressure on
diastole. Furthermore the use of nerve stimulation
through transcutaneous electricity or massage
reduces the feeling of anxious and pain on SEFT
therapy which in subsequence will fix or accelerate
blood flow dilated system on both hypertensive and
normotensive subjects
7 21
CONCLUSION
Statistically there is significant effect of dark
chocolate and SEFT therapy combination towards
anxiety level blood pressure on systole and heart
slide 7: Fitriana R et al / Int. J. of Allied Med. Sci. and Clin. Research Vol-63 2018 654-661
660
pulse on primigravida pregnant women. The
finding of this research can be used as alternative
medicine for midwives to use in handling anxiety
during pregnancy. It is suggested to consider dark
chocolate inclusion in class program for pregnant
women for 1 time/day and SEFT therapy for 20
minutes to reduce anxiety level and fix blood
circulation problems to improve the healthiness of
the mother and her baby.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The authors would like to acknowledge all
subjects who have participated in the study. We
would also like to thank Dr. Drg. Diyah Fatmasari
MDSC Dr.dr. Suryati Kumorowulan M. Biotech
Mardiyono MNS PhD Dr.Melyana Nurul
Widyawati S.SiT.M.Kes for their commitment and
support throughout this study the Bumijawa Health
Center which has helped the course of this study
and especially to parents who have funded this
research.
REFERENCES
1. Susilowati DSuryani N Murti B.Pengaruh Dukungan Keluarga dan paritas Terhadap Kecemasan Ibu Hamil
TM III dalam Menghadapi Persalinan di RB Harapan Bunda Surakarta. Jurnal Kedokteran Indonesia .31
2012.
2. MandagiDPali CSinolunganJ. Perbedaan Tingkat Kecemasan Pada Primigravida dan Multigravida di RSIA
Kasih Ibu Manado. jurnal e-biomedik 11 2013.
3. Hafid R Abdul BNaimM Fuqaan. The Determinant Affecting Labour Stress Primigravida In Mongolato
Health Centre Gorontalo Reagency Gorontalo Province. Skripsi. Gorontalo:Puskesmas Mongotalo 2013.
4. PrismaniaP Wagiya Elisa. Hubungan Pendampingan Suami dengan Tingkat Kecemasan Ibu Primigravida
dalam Menghadapi Proses Persalinan Kala I di Rumah Bersalin Kota Ungaran. Semarang :Universitas
Muhammadiyah Semarang 2017.
5. Endah K. Farmakologi Kehamilan.available from: http//ggoggoma.wordpress.com 2014.
6. Siswoto Hadi P. S. A. Perbedaan Tingkat Kecemasan Antara Ibu Hamil Primigravida Dan Multigravida
Dalam Menghadapi Persalinan. Banyuwangi: Akad. Kesehat. RUSTIDA 2016
7. Claresta L. J Purwoko Y. Pengaruh Konsumsi Cokelat Terhadap Tingkat kecemasan mahasiswa Fakultas
Kedokteran Andalas .jurnal kedokteran diponegoro 6 2017 737–747.
8. Inggriane Puspita. Fauzia D. h. Pengaruh Terapi Seft Terhadap Penurunan Tingkat Kecemasan Pada Para
Pengguna Napza. jurnal Keperawatan Muhammadiyah Sekol. Tinggi Ilmu Kesehat. Aisyiyah Bandung 2 2017.
9. SY Wong. PL Lua. Effects of Dark Chocolate Consumption on Anxiety Depressive Symptoms and Health-
related Quality of Life Status among Cancer Patients. Heal. Environ. J. 3 2012 27–35.
10. Kristanto A. Bisnis dan Manfaat Cokelat Untung dan Sehat Semakin Mendekat. penerbit pustaka baru press
2012.
11. Dharma K. kusuma. Metode Penelitian Keperawatan. penerbit : Trans Info Media 2016.
12. Nurazizah E. Tih F. Suwindere W. Gigi F. K. Maranatha U. K. Black Chocolate Consumption Reduces
Subjective Symptoms in 18-22 Years Old Females with Premenstrual Syndrome Faculty of Medicine
Maranatha Christian University Faculty of Dentistry Maranatha Christian University. J. Med. Heal. 1 2015
76–84.
13. Perdiansyah. kandungan flavonoid total pada cokelat. visited th 2018.
14. Ayunsari B. R. Fasikhah S. S. Karmiyati D. Tingkat Kecemasan Penderita Diabetes Mellitus Sensory
Relaxation Awareness To Lower Anxiety.jurnal intervensi psikologi: Fakultas Psikologi Universitas
Muhammadiyah Malang. 4 2012 269–286
15. Prasetyaningrum S. Fasikhah S. S. Karmiyati D. Terapi Kognitif Untuk Mereduksi Tingkat Kecemasan
Pada Pasien Pasca Stroke. .jurnal intervensi psikologi: Fakultas Psikologi Universitas Muhammadiyah
malang.4 2012 113–137
16. HanumL. Hubungan antara harapan orangtua dan keyakinan diri dengan stress akademik siswa kelas
unggulan. kudus : fakultas psikologi universitas muria kudu 82 2013.
17. Vidianti. Pengaruh Pemberian Cokelat terhadap pre menstrual syndrome. Univ. Brawijaya 2010.
18. Kushartanti W. Soekamti E. R. Sriwahyuniati C. F. Senam hamil: menyamankan kehamilan
slide 8: Fitriana R et al / Int. J. of Allied Med. Sci. and Clin. Research Vol-63 2018 654-661
661
mempermudah persalinan. Lintang Pustaka 2004.
19. Adams SJ. a critical look at the effect of cocoa on human health. nutr Aust. ntional Newsl. winter 10–3 2004.
20. Carolia N. et al. n Dark Chocolate to Prevent Preeclampsia in Pregnancy.Majority : Fakultas kedokteran
universitas lampung 5 2016 59–62.
21. Mulia Hakam Krisna Yetti R. T. S. H. Intervensi Spiritual Emotional Freedom Technique SEFT untuk
mengurangi rasa nyeri Pasien Kanker. Makara Kesehat. 132 2009.
How to cite this article: Fitriana Rakhimah Diyah Fatmasari Suryati Kumorowulan. The
combination of dark chocolate and spiritual emotional freedom technique SEFT towards anxiety
level and blood pressure on primigravida pregnancy women. Int J of Allied Med Sci and Clin Res
2018 63: 654-661.
Source of Support: Nil. Conflict of Interest: None declared.